Research Bulletin 20: is policy uncertainty altogether bad?

Policy Dynamics in the Euro Area

with Ana Paula Ribeiro (MACGROW)

Research in a Tweet: Policy uncertainty shapes fiscal outcomes. It amplifies the effect of temporary shocks in government spending and weakens that of permanent ones. Credit responsiveness across Euro Area countries is heterogeneous, influenced by the size of banks and the financial health of firms. It is important to adapt and coordinate policies to address the economic diversity of those countries, eventually through the mediation of the ECB.

In the labyrinthine world of macroeconomic policy, Ana Paula Ribeiro’s (MACGROW) work evinces the importance of adaptable and coordinated policy frameworks to navigate the Euro Area’s diverse and constrained economic landscape.


In a study with Nuno Gonçalves (Banco de Portugal), Paula delves into fiscal policy effectiveness amidst growing policy uncertainty. They show that imperfect information significantly influences the multipliers of fiscal policy. Specifically, it increases the multiplier of temporary fiscal shocks while reducing that of permanent ones. According to Paula, this suggests that uncertainty about the nature of a fiscal shock increases the efficiency of stabilization fiscal policies. "This result has several implications, reinforcing the normative recommendation that permanent debt consolidation efforts should be enacted during times of high uncertainty or the observation that expansionary policies during elections, and thus more uncertain times, have weaker effects."


Transitioning to monetary policy, in a study with Carolina Araújo (Banco de Portugal) and Vítor Carvalho (MACGROW), Paula finds significant heterogeneity within the Euro Area in the transmission of monetary policy through the credit channel. Specifically, the reactivity of credit granted is more pronounced in countries characterized by banks with above-average size or non-financial firms with lower profitability and higher debt levels. This underscores the heightened effectiveness of the credit channel in countries like Greece and Portugal. "These results recommend country-specific policy measures or ways to harmonize the banking system and the corporate landscape across member countries, as they face common shocks."


In other contributions with Celsa Machado (MACGROW) and Tatiana Kirsanova (U.Glasgow), the result of research partnership and life-long friendship, Paula further explores the nuanced interplay between monetary and fiscal policies, how high debt levels constrain stabilization in smaller countries, or the challenges and strategies surrounding the Zero Lower Bound. She is keen on exploring issues on demand-side stabilization policies or studying and assessing the determinants of policy effectiveness and its unequal effects across countries in the Euro Area.

Click to learn more about this research

Ana Paula Ribeiro is Assistant Professor at FEP. She may be reached at aribeiro@fep.up.pt.

Did you know that Jeppe Druedahl is visiting cef.up this week to teach an advanced course on heterogeneous agents in macroeconomics?

Would you like one of our next bulletins to be about you and your research? Let us know at cefup.bulletin@fep.up.pt

Copyright © 2024 * CEF.UP * All rights reserved.
The views and opinions expressed in this Bulletin do not necessarily reflect those of CEF.UP, FEP or the University of Porto.

Our communications are independent of those of FEP. If you do not wish to receive any of our communications, please click here.